Quick verdict
For paper crafts scrapbooking, the key choice is whether you want a journal-centered kit to build pages in or a smaller assortment of stickers and ephemera to decorate projects you already have. The Vintage Scrapbooking Supplies Kit, 185Pcs Junk Journal Kit with Scrapbook Paper is the stronger match for an A5 junk-journal setup with a dotted format, cardboard cover, and green vintage styling. The Vintage Scrapbooking Supplies Kit Vintage Stickers for Scrapbooking Journaling suits projects that call for assorted decorative pieces, including stickers, notes, cards, bookmarks, tags, lace paper, and hemp rope.
The listed prices are separated by $5.76: the sticker-focused kit is USD 13.95, while the 185-piece journal kit is USD 19.71. Pick based on the kind of page you want to make, not just the number of pieces.
| Comparison point | 185Pcs Junk Journal Kit with Scrapbook Paper | Vintage Stickers for Scrapbooking Journaling |
|---|---|---|
| Listed price | USD 19.71 | USD 13.95 |
| Core format | A5, dotted, soft-cover journal format | Sheet-form sticker and paper ephemera assortment |
| Color and finish details | Green; cardboard cover | Assorted; matte finish; fade resistant |
| Decorative direction | Vintage ephemera with nature, retro items, people, flowers, and butterflies | Vintage cottagecore-style stickers and paper ephemera |
Where each kit wins
Choose the 185Pcs Junk Journal Kit for a page-building starting point
This kit fits shoppers who want the journal itself to be part of the project. Its A5 sheet size, dotted ruling, and soft cardboard cover provide a defined place to assemble collage spreads rather than only supplying loose decorations. The listed vintage ephemera theme-nature, retro things, people, flowers, and butterflies-also gives a clear visual direction for layered journal pages. Its 185-piece format makes sense when you want one coordinated collection for ongoing junk journaling.
Choose the Vintage Sticker Kit for flexible decorating pieces
This option is geared toward embellishing a range of paper projects: journals, collages, scrapbooks, invitations, menus, organizers, and themed-party crafts are all named uses. The mix includes aesthetic stickers alongside vintage paper, notes, light paper cards, bookmarks, tags, lace paper, and hemp rope. Choose it when you want assorted accents to combine with your own notebook, scrapbook, or paper base, especially if matte-finish sticker elements are central to your layout.
Product notes
185Pcs Junk Journal Kit with Scrapbook Paper
Make this your pick when your project starts with a dedicated journal rather than a pile of standalone decorations. The A5 size and dotted ruling give it a recognizable writing-and-collage structure, while the soft cardboard cover makes the kit feel oriented toward a contained junk-journaling project. Its vintage mix of nature motifs, people, flowers, butterflies, and retro objects can help keep a spread visually cohesive without shifting between unrelated styles. The 185-piece count also supports a more expansive collection of materials for multiple layers and pages. The trade-off is its listed green color: it is best suited to shoppers who want that color within their vintage paper-craft palette.
Vintage Stickers for Scrapbooking Journaling
Choose this kit when decorative variety matters more than receiving a journal format. Its 83-piece collection is built around 45 aesthetic stickers, supported by vintage paper, notes, paper cards, bookmarks, tags, lace paper, and hemp rope. That composition works well for adding detail to pages, invitations, menus, and other paper crafts where you already have a surface to decorate. The assorted color approach and matte finish complement a mixed-ephemera look, while the fade-resistant feature is specifically listed for the kit. Its limitation is the sticker-and-ephemera emphasis: shoppers seeking an A5 dotted journal with a cover will find that structure in the 185Pcs kit instead.
Final choice by use case
Pick the 185Pcs Junk Journal Kit with Scrapbook Paper for a green, vintage-themed A5 journal experience where dotted pages and a covered format are part of the plan. Pick the Vintage Stickers for Scrapbooking Journaling for assorted matte decorative pieces that can personalize existing journals, scrapbook pages, invitations, and collage projects. The first is for building within a defined journal; the second is for embellishing across different paper-craft formats.
